Fáilte chuig gaa.ie - suíomh oifigiúil CLG

Football

AIB Ulster Club SFC: Scotstown advance following penalty drama

Shane Carey, Scotstown, and Noah Barrett, St Eunan's, in AIB Ulster Club SFC action. Photo by Matthew Harvey/Sportsfile

Shane Carey, Scotstown, and Noah Barrett, St Eunan's, in AIB Ulster Club SFC action. Photo by Matthew Harvey/Sportsfile

AIB Ulster Club SFC Semi-Final

Scotstown 1-24 St Eunan's 0-27 AET

Scotstown win 4-2 on penalties

By Chris McNulty at Brewster Park

Defending champions Scotstown prevailed on penalties to return to the Ulster Club SFC final

A gripping game at Brewster Park was settled on penalties after a Kieran Hughes free levelled things up in the last minute of extra time.

Hughes fired high into the chilly Enniskillen sky after Brian MacIntyre fouled Max Maguire and the Donegal champions were pipped on penalties.

A dramatic and thrilling Oran Winston point, with just seconds left in normal time, saw St Eunan’s - managed by former Scotstown boss Kieran Donnelly - force extra time.

Corner-back Darragh Murray plundered a goal for Scotstown in the 55th minute and it looked enough for the holders. However, Eoin Dowling put the game firmly in the melting pot when he fired over early in added-on time at the end.

Still, it seemed as if Scotstown would hang on until Winston - a grandson of Donegal great Joe ‘Dodo’ Winston - found his range with a brilliant two-point kick from the left-hand side to earn an extra period for his side.

In extra time, St Eunan’s penchant for two pointers in this one came to the fore. A pair of inspirational kicks from distance by MacIntyre and Dowling helped St Eunan’s to lead only for a Hughes free to level it up and send it to penalties.

Rory Beggan, Darren Hughes, Shane Carey all netted for Scotstown while Niall O’Donnell and Dylan Doogan scored for St Eunan’s. Shaun Patton saved from Kieran Hughes while Beggan denied Pauric McGettigan and James Kelly fired wide to leave it for Conor McCarthy - excellent throughout for Scotstown - to slot home the winning kick.

It seemed an age since, after Scotstown had plenty of the ball in the opening moments, St Eunan’s forward Conor O’Donnell Jnr opened the scoring in the fifth minute.

Eoin McGeehin quickly followed and when Caolan Ward won possession from the subsequent kick-out, St Eunan’s patiently held possession before Oran Winston tucked over for a three-point lead.

Conor McCarthy kicked over a two-pointer to get Scotstown off the mark in the ninth minute. The Monaghan kingpins had to wait a further nine minutes for their next flag, Mattie Maguire drilling over after McGeehin fisted over at the other end.

St Eunan’s wore black armbands in memory of Peter Patton, the father of goalkeeper Shaun Patton whose funeral took place nine days beforehand following his sudden death which sent shockwaves rippling throughout Donegal.

Patton stepped up to deliciously clip over a two-point free from just outside the arc in the 26th minute. Patton’s coolly-converted free was swiftly followed by McGeehin, again with his fist, adding another to open a three-point advantage, 0-7 to 0-4.

Scotstown, who had to dig deep for a 2-21 to 2-20 win over O’Donovan Rossa in their quarter-final, flipped the game on its head in the last few minutes of the first half.

McCarthy landed a free and Donnchadh Connolly added his name to the scoresheet before Tommy Mallen arrowed over a two-pointer to put the Farney men ahead for the first time.

Scotstown captain Rory Beggan belied the 65-metre distance to sail over a free, out of his hands, for a 0-10 to 0-7 half-time lead.

It could have been greater but, just before the purple patch began for Scotstown, Mattie Maguire shot against the outside of the post after being played in.

Maguire and McCarthy stretched the Scotstown lead early in the second half, but Shane O’Donnell - the Donegal joint captain - found his range for a two-pointer.

His brother, Niall O’Donnell, was back in tow for St Eunan’s having missed their quarter-final win over Erne Gaels.

O’Donnell has been commuting back and forth from Chicago due to work, but arrived in Ireland on Monday to give the Donegal champions a considerable boost and he reduced the arrears with a pair of delightful scores to bring his side to within two (0-14 to 0-12).

Nicky Sherlock and McCarthy extended Scotstown’s lead, but O’Donnell nailed a two-pointer, a timely reminder that the black and amber wouldn’t be wilting.

Sherlock, though, opened up the three-point margin again (0-17 to 0-14) with 10 minutes remaining.

Shane O’Donnell thumped over from long range to raise another orange flag and bring it back to the minimum before Luke McGuinness evened the sums in the 53rd minute - just after veteran Hughes, despite a heavily-strapped knee, was drafted in by Scotstown.

Soon after, Murray - after Hughes won a kick-out - struck gold for Scotstown, who seemed destined for the final only for Winston to pull the embers from the fire to force extra time.

Shane Carey, Ryan O’Toole and Sherlock gave Scotstown the edge in the opening half of extra time and Max Maguire had a sight of goal only to clip the St Eunan’s goal frame when caught in two minds in a moment that could have put the night beyond the Donegal side’s reach.

A Niall O’Donnell free meant that St Eunan’s were two down, 1-21 to 0-22, at the break in extra time but they even managed to get themselves into the driving seat, albeit briefly.

Ultimately, they were left to ponder one that crept away from them.

Scorers for Scotstown: Conor McCarthy (1f, 1tpf) 0-5, Tommy Mallen (1tp) 0-4, Nicky Sherlock 0-3, Darragh Murray 1-0, Shane Carey (2f), Mattie Maguire, Rory Beggan (1tpf), Kieran Hughes (1f) 0-2 each, Ryan O’Toole, Donnchadh Connolly, Francis Maguire, Max Maguire 0-1 each

Scorers for St Eunan’s: Niall O’Donnell 0-5 (1f, 1tp), Shane O’Donnell 0-4 (2tp), Eoin Dowling (1tp), Oran Winston (1tp), Conor O’Donnell Jnr (1f), Eoin McGeehin 0-3 each, Brian MacIntyre, Shaun Patton (1 2ptf) 0-2 each, Conor O’Donnell Snr, Luke McGuinness 0-1 each.

Scotstown: Rory Beggan; Mark McCaffrey, Ryan O’Toole, Darragh Murray; Donnchadh Connolly, Damien McArdle, Conor McCarthy; Micheal McCarville, Darren Hughes; Gavin McPhillips, Shane Carey, Francis Maguire; Tommy Mallen, Nicky Sherlock, Mattie Maguire.

Subs: Max Maguire for F Maguire (47), Kieran Hughes for McPhillips (53), Sean Og McElwain for Mattie Maguire (55), James Hamill for Connolly (60+3), Mark McPhillips for Sherlock (68).

St Eunan’s: Shaun Patton; Noah Barrett, Caolan Ward, Josh Hay; Kieran Tobin, Conor O’Donnell Snr, Oran Winston; James Kelly, Eoin Dowling; Ciaran Moore, Shane O’Donnell, Luke McGuinness; Eoin McGeehin, Niall O’Donnell, Conor O’Donnell Jnr.

Subs: Dylan Doogan for McGeehin (60), Brian MacIntyre for Hay (68), Evan Daly for Barrett (71), Pauric McGettigan for O’Donnell Jnr (71).

Referee: Kieran Eannetta (Tyrone).