Fáilte chuig gaa.ie - suíomh oifigiúil CLG

Feature

How adapted games can help better balance competition with participation among 13-17 year olds

O'Donovan Rossa Magherafelt players huddle at the 2026 John West Féile Peile na nÓg Gaelic Football and LGFA National Finals at the Find Insurance Owenbeg Derry GAA Centre in Owenbeg, Derry. Photo by Shauna Clinton/Sportsfile

O'Donovan Rossa Magherafelt players huddle at the 2026 John West Féile Peile na nÓg Gaelic Football and LGFA National Finals at the Find Insurance Owenbeg Derry GAA Centre in Owenbeg, Derry. Photo by Shauna Clinton/Sportsfile

The GAA last week published a new research report titled ‘Shaping the Future of Juvenile Gaelic Games: Evidence to Inform a Youth Games Framework’ which can be viewed and downloaded below.

The report identifies important findings concerning meaningful game time, player development, competition structures, and retention among 13–17-year-olds.

GAA.ie sat down with the authors of the report, Dr Michael McKay, Dr Paul Donnelly, Dr Richard Bowles, and Dr Peter Horgan, to discuss the huge breadth of work that went into it and how the Association might better produce an evidence-informed games programme that should remain competitive but not at the expense of participation, development, enjoyment, belonging and long-term retention.

***

GAA.ie: Peter, can you explain how this report builds on previous projects the Gaelic games governing bodies have undertaken on young players’ involvement in Gaelic games?

Peter Horgan: It would have started off with ‘The Gaelic Games Youth Participation Study’ where we engaged over 5,000 players age 13 to 18 to understand what it means to be involved in Gaelic games, what participation looks like for them, their experiences of playing and being coached. Their attitudes towards involvement and what they what they consider important and whether and why they might continue to participate in Gaelic games into the future.

Subsequently, we built on that with some other research with partners in DCU that looked at things like the experience of participating in Gaelic games at youth level, the experiences of coaches in things like ability grouping and streaming, and the experience of players and parents in ability grouping and streaming as well.

This is another element of that larger thread of youth participation research that is specifically looking at game structures and formats and how they can support participation development and retention amongst players in that 13 to 17 age cohort.

GAA.ie: Michael, you led the research programme, can you give me an insight into the breadth of work that has gone into this report?

Michael McKay: We took a five-level approach to it. We first engaged with the Provincial Heads of Games and then with the Heads of Games in four counties who were already on the road to adapted games to get their lived experience. That informed then the material content of the public survey.

Simultaneous to all of that there was a Delphi process. Coaches, administrators, and academics, informed by the most recent piece of work, for example, the views of games managers, or the results of the public survey, gave their views on adapted games. You almost had an iterative process of challenge to their thinking. So, the very last stage of the Delphi study would have been this expert core group informed by the totality of the process wave on wave.

Peter Horgan: That group was challenged both ways. The findings challenged their thinking on certain topics, but, equally, some of their critiques or criticisms or comments would have challenged our thinking on how the project was progressing as well.

Michael McKay: 100 per cent. So, you had the Provincial Heads of Games. You had the four counties representing lived experience, you had the public survey, you had the Delphi running concurrent to all of that, and then the icing on the cake was the scientific angle at Abbottstown where Brendan Murphy from Antrim came in and helped us with field testing adapted games. I’d really like to thank Brendan, the clubs involved, and the GAA staff who gave us such great support in Abbottstown. We videoed the games and we tagged the activities in the games and were able to demonstrate that with modifications to playing numbers and playing space that various metrics were changed. People were either on the ball more or less. There was more or less shooting. There was more or less tackling. This meant that the theory derived from the interviews and surveys could actually be stress tested.

For me, what that totality offers is a 360 degree look at attitudes towards and behaviour within adapted games processes.

Dr Peter Horgan: There have been similar projects in other sports and other countries. What's different here is the breadth and depth of the work Michael outlined, and the combination of different research approaches to build a broader understanding of what is happening.

There have been many studies of small-sided games and of changing pitch sizes and playing numbers. What makes this work different is that it brings together the perspectives of all the different stakeholders, giving us a broader and more rounded understanding of what's happening for this age group.

The 16 recommendations from put forward in ‘Shaping the Future of Juvenile Gaelic Games: Evidence to Inform a Youth Games Framework’.

The 16 recommendations from put forward in ‘Shaping the Future of Juvenile Gaelic Games: Evidence to Inform a Youth Games Framework’.

GAA.ie: Peter, some recent inaccurate online commentary suggested this report would propose making games for the 13-17 age cohort non-competitive which simply isn’t true. Can you talk about some of the recommendations the report does make?

Peter Horgan: The central message here is that we can have a clear pathway from Go Games to adult participation with playing opportunities and competition structures that reflect the developmental needs of the players of those different age cohorts as they grow and develop. Competition is very important to young people. They've told us this. In fact, in the Youth Participation Study when we asked players about their intention to continue playing the number one reason that people gave when they were asked why you intend to continue playing was that they enjoyed being competitive. Now, that was different from saying they wanted to win because that was an option as well in the survey question and it wasn't in the top three responses provided by the young people.

So, the enjoyment they get from being competitive is an important part of it. I think the piece here for us is to see how we can ensure meaningful playing opportunities with appropriate competition structures and appropriate coaching from the various coaches of their various teams as players progress through adolescence.

The aim is not to make underage Gaelic games less competitive; it's about looking at how our games and competitions are organized and whether they give players the best possible experience whatever their ability or age group. We know that there's no one single reason that people stop playing. But we know things like enjoyment and playing time, confidence in their own ability, feeling part of a team, coaching, as well as other demands are all important in people's intention to continue participating in Gaelic games.

Paul Donnelly: Competition is hugely important, and I think that came through very clearly in the research. Young people want to compete. They want to win games, represent their clubs and test themselves against the best. They enjoy the excitement of preparing for meaningful games, whether that's in leagues or championships.

I think everyone involved in Gaelic games, whether as a player, coach, parent or volunteer, understands the importance of competition and the role that leagues and championships play in our clubs. There's absolutely no question about that.

But what this research encourages us to consider is how we organise competition at different stages of a young person's development, and whether the structures we have in place are providing the best possible experience for all young players.

So, for example, there may be opportunities to use league competitions to introduce greater flexibility around playing formats and meaningful game time, while retaining the importance, tradition and competitive nature of championships. That's just one possibility, and these are matters that require further consideration and discussion. The important point is that competition and player development are not competing priorities. They should complement each other. And I think that's something we sometimes lose sight of. We need to think about how competition can help young people become better players, challenge themselves and enjoy their involvement in Gaelic games, while also encouraging them to remain involved in the longer term.

We also need to be mindful of the experiences of young players who regularly find themselves watching from the sidelines, sometimes because younger or more physically developed players are selected ahead of them. We have to ask ourselves what that experience means for their confidence, enjoyment and willingness to remain involved. That doesn't mean removing competition or taking away the desire to win. Far from it. It means thinking more carefully about how we balance competitive opportunities with the developmental needs of young people.

The detailed consideration of playing formats and competition structures is a discussion for another day. But I do think the research provides a strong evidence base for having that conversation.

Ultimately, the challenge is not whether young people should compete. They absolutely should. The challenge is how we organise competition so that it develops better players, provides meaningful opportunities and keeps more young people involved in Gaelic games for longer.

Self-reported reasons why young people participate in Gaelic games. 

Self-reported reasons why young people participate in Gaelic games. 

Richard Bowles: The recommendations are based on the huge variety of research sources Michael mentioned, and they build very effectively on the reports Peter has referred to.

They also build on good practice that we know is already happening in some counties. For example, Fermanagh, Leitrim, and Longford have already begun adapting games to suit their own circumstances.

During the compilation of the report, we had an opportunity to look at that good practice and perhaps bring some of it to a national audience so we can build a suite of options that different counties and perhaps different areas within counties can consider when deciding what they can provide for their players. It's important to recognise that some of this is already happening.

I think this report gives us an opportunity to start a discussion about what meaningful, authentic game experiences might look like in those different contexts. One thing that came through clearly was that, when playing adapted games, players want to play with full-size goalposts.

They don't want to play with the small goalposts they used when they were eight or ten. So that provision of an authentic game experience is really important. Research outside Gaelic games is also useful here, particularly the idea of meaningful participation.

A lot of work has been done on this in physical education and youth sport. It highlights the importance of social interaction and personally relevant experiences which are things that make experiences meaningful.

The research also discusses competition but frames it in terms of challenge. So that the challenge should be appropriate for different players at different times.

The discussions that follow this report might consider what an appropriate challenge looks like for different players at different times. That may help us reframe the discussion around competition. Competition doesn't just have to mean winning the county title at the end of the process.

Different players can be challenged in different ways that are appropriate to them at that particular time. That brings me back to the excellent work that has been done through Go Games over the last 20 years, but the transition can feel like a cliff face. You finish Go Games and move straight into full blown 15-a-side competition. For our teenage cohort, aged 13 to 17, we need a graduated approach.

The experience for a 13-year-old just leaving Go Games has to be fundamentally different from that of a 17-year-old who is probably ready to move into adult competition. Currently, I don't think we really have that graduated approach. This report gives us an opportunity to start conversations around the experience for a 13-year-old moving from Go Games, where everyone played and had plenty of game time, into a more competitive environment.

There is no one-size-fits-all answer, but the report may prompt people to consider how we help children and young teenagers move into the next phase of their development.

Peter Horgan: When we're looking at competition structures what I think people want from competitions is that there's regular and meaningful games for players across that range of abilities where there's a realistic opportunity to contribute and where there's appropriate challenge.

Things like grading, fixture schedules, and the balance between leagues and championships and other formats. There's a huge opportunity for the organization to be very innovative around those things and to be able to provide those meaningful games for players across the different age groups and different levels of ability whilst being conscious of hurling and football and geographical balance and all of those type of things.

The question becomes how can we ensure that players have that worthwhile program of games, that meaningful program of games, while preserving the competition that they value?

Michael McKay: We asked players in the public survey to self-rate their ability and we split them into groups of the top third, the middle third, and the bottom third in terms of their own perceived competency. Across four of the five indicators - to be fit and healthy, for fun and enjoyment, to be with your friends, and to learn new skills or improve existing ones - a majority of each of those thirds said that was very important in terms of engagement with Gaelic games.

I think that's a huge finding. That the vast majority young people who come to Gaelic games do so to be fit and healthy, for fun and enjoyment, to be with your friends, and to learn new skills and improve existing ones. The one that is different to the others is the response to the prompt 'To win competitions'. That elicited a notably different response profile. Among the players who rated themselves as better players, more than twice the proportion of those compared to those who were in the bottom third said that winning competitions was very important.

I think it's not a mathematical stretch to say that even for the third of people who identify themselves as good players, to win competitions isn't even proportionately the biggest issue for them. I think that's an important story. There is a cohort for whom winning is important, but those same people value other things more than the winning.

The wellbeing, enjoyment and development are key, whilst not obviously throwing away competitiveness. Those are things that the players identify as key priorities for them.

So, I do think there is an argument for differentiation in how young people are engaged in Gaelic games. There are a proportion for whom winning is very important, but across all ability levels, everybody values being fit and healthy, being with their friends, and improving their skills more highly.

This for me is an important loop back into coaching. There's a big, big call in this report for coaches to be sensitive to that. That comes from parents and it comes from young people. One of the stats that jumped out at me which was quite alarming was that 39 per cent of parents said that at least one of their children had stopped playing Gaelic games. That's a massive call to action in terms of, ‘why is that?’

I think the 16 recommendations make demands of the Association. They are not passive, neutral commentary. They are actually calls to behavioural change. I think this report represents a massive challenge, not just around competition. There are other massive issues.

Paul Donnelly: From my perspective, one of the most encouraging findings was just how much young people value Gaelic games. Almost 90% of the young people who responded said they enjoyed playing Gaelic games.

They also placed considerable emphasis on developing their skills, spending time with friends, and competing. What I found interesting was that more than 40 per cent agreed that the strongest players should receive more game time. To me, that shows that young people clearly recognise the role and value of competition.

As Peter and Michael have already said, there is a willingness to try to compete and to be successful. Another figure that stood out was that 95 per cent believe every player should have meaningful opportunities to develop and contribute. That's quite different from game time.

Young people clearly value the games. However, 7.5 per cent of the young players who responded to the survey indicated that they hardly ever got any game time.

Many people might say that is a very small percentage, but it's worth considering what it means for a young person. If someone under 14 or 15 is training regularly, making themselves available for training and matches, travelling to matches, but gets no game time, that can affect how they perceive and enjoy the game, their confidence and motivation, and, most importantly, their decision about whether to stay involved.

So, while we should be encouraged by the overwhelmingly positive experiences reported by young players, we also have a collective responsibility to reflect on those aspects of the playing experience that could be improved.

Key findings from modified games.

Key findings from modified games.

GAA.ie: How did the smaller-sided matches on appropriately scaled pitches that you experimented with in Abbotstown impact player participation?

Peter Horgan: I think meaningful participation is more than just standing on the pitch. When you're on the pitch playing, are you actually able to get involved in the game? That's one reason to look at the small-sided nature of some of the games.

Across the different types of games, we coded what are called 'events'. An event might be a catch, a puck-out, a kick, a sideline, a score or a wide. Those are all different examples of events.

We coded about 3,000 events across the games we analysed. The data showed that changing the playing numbers, and pitch size affected both the number and the type of events in those games. For example, in an 11-a-side game on a full-size pitch, there was a lower proportion of events.

When we reduced the pitch size but kept the teams at 11-a-side, the number of events increased. There were more catches, kicks, puck-outs and other types of involvement. When we changed both the pitch dimensions and the playing numbers, the types of involvement also changed.

For example, in under-14 hurling, 11-a-side on a small pitch produced the highest number of stick passes and blocks. Under-14 hurling, 9-a-side on a smaller pitch, produced higher numbers of tackles, goals and long deliveries. The types of involvement can change depending on the game format. That leads us to believe that from a skill-acquisition and development perspective, changing the pitch and playing numbers can influence the emphasis on different elements of the game, such as catching, striking, scoring or long deliveries.

To give a football example, in under-14 football there was a significant difference in the number of tackles between 11-a-side on a full pitch and 11-a-side on a small pitch. Changing the pitch dimensions, as well as the playing numbers, can affect the level and type of involvement players have in the game.

Michael McKay: Good evidence for that is on page 38 of the report which directly compares 11-a-side on a full pitch with 11-a-side on a small pitch in hurling and football. Over the same 10-minute period, reducing the pitch while keeping the numbers the same resulted in 59 more events in hurling and 66 more in football. These included contests, ball-use events and shots.

All of those increased in both codes. If you want the game to be more intense, or players to operate under greater pressure, that modification supports that aim.

It's also about practically fulfilling fixtures programs so that things like exam periods and holiday times don't mean that everything grinds to a halt because a team doesn't have 15 players. There's also a practical element to this.

If it's down as low as 9 or 10 a side, we play 9 or 10 a side and that game carries the same weight as a game that would be 15 a side. So, there are other practical benefits as well as benefits in terms of skill acquisition and exposure to competitive environments for players of all abilities.

GAA.ie: The report also underlines how smaller-sided games and more flexible formats could also help with the urgent challenge that Ireland’s changing demographics pose to clubs.

Peter Horgan: The purpose of this wasn't demographics but it's an aligned area of work. We know from the demographics report that there are two related elements that are happening. Firstly, rural clubs who are struggling to field teams independently anymore, and secondly larger clubs who have significant numbers of players.

One of the one of the challenges in the small clubs obviously is not being able to field 15-a-side teams. What this looks at is the program of games we might be able to provide at fewer than 15-a-side. That wasn't a direct intended element of this research, but it is a related piece to the research.

So, what might the games look like for those clubs who can't field at 15-a-side anymore on their own but who do want to field on their own in a given year and to have their jersey on the field rather than just be part of an independent team?

As regards the urban clubs, I think one of the challenges in Gaelic games is that if you have 17 players you've one team and if you have 27 players you still only one team. We do know for those clubs that have larger playing numbers that sometimes the competition formats might be overly restrictive in terms of facilitating larger numbers of players playing.

So is there an opportunity for those larger clubs to be able to enter multiple smaller sided teams which would allow them to give adequate game time to all of their players which we know is a huge part in player retention.

GAA.IE: One of the six priorities for the future of juvenile games outlined in the report is to develop better coaches. How do we do that?

Paul Donnelly. The first thing I would say is that we have thousands of volunteer coaches across Gaelic games who do absolutely brilliant work, week in and week out. And I think it's really important that we acknowledge that.

Without those coaches, our clubs and our games simply wouldn't function. So, this research is certainly not about criticising coaches. It's about understanding how we can better support them in what is an increasingly important and sometimes challenging role.

I think we need to recognise that coaching young people is about much more than preparing a team to win its next match. It's about understanding how young people develop, recognising that they develop at different rates, and creating an environment where every player has an opportunity to improve, enjoy their involvement and feel valued.

Whether you're working with the strongest player on the team or someone who is still developing their skills and confidence, both deserve a positive experience and appropriate opportunities to progress.

Our research reinforces the importance of positive coaching environments, good communication, appropriate challenges and meaningful opportunities to play. It also raises important questions about the pressure to win at younger ages and whether that can sometimes come at the expense of longer-term player development.

And I think that's something we need to reflect on collectively.

Coaches want to win games. That's perfectly natural, and there's absolutely nothing wrong with that. But I think most coaches also want to see young players improving, enjoying their hurling, football or camogie, and progressing through the age groups.

The challenge is how we help coaches balance those ambitions, recognising that winning games and developing players should not be mutually exclusive.

That's where the wider organisation has a really important responsibility.

We need to ensure that coaches have access to appropriate education, ongoing development, practical support and competition structures that help them make good decisions in the interests of young players.

And I think we also need to be careful about making generalisations. This research doesn't tell us how many coaches are doing a good job or how many might need additional support. What it does provide is evidence about young people's experiences and some of the areas where we can collectively improve.

So, for me, there are two sides to this.

We need to challenge the Association to consider how effectively it supports, educates and develops its coaches. But equally, we need to encourage coaches themselves to reflect on their own practices and the experiences they are providing for young people.

Coaches strongly endorsed the principle of equal treatment in training, while recognising the practical complexity of applying this to match-day selection.

Coaches strongly endorsed the principle of equal treatment in training, while recognising the practical complexity of applying this to match-day selection.

Peter Horgan: Coaches are volunteers who give their time freely several times a week for the benefit of Gaelic games, their communities, and the players in their care.

That places an obligation on us as an organisation to ask how can we best support those coaches best? What materials, resources, educational opportunities and other supports can we provide, given the demands on their time and their commitment to improving our games?

We know that players notice the quality of coaching, and that it impacts their enjoyment of the game, so there's a huge opportunity to improve player enjoyment by helping coaches do their jobs.

Returning to the Youth Participation Study, we discussed the importance of autonomy-supportive behaviours. Players who described their coaches as demonstrating high levels of these behaviours reported greater satisfaction with their involvement and a stronger intention to continue playing than players who rated their coaches poorly in this area. There is a link between coach behaviour, player enjoyment, and player retention.

Competition structures also inform and influence coaching behaviour. Competition structures may contribute to poorer behaviour from coaches and parents on the sidelines. When the pressure is to win the championship, the shouting and roaring that comes with that pressure can be intensified.

We need to remain faithful to what we found through our research, while recognising that coaches operate in a nuanced environment and that their role is not necessarily easy.

Michael McKay: Our research has shown that the type of coaching that players appreciate is warm, encouraging and inclusive coaching.

There was a call for a move away from coach-centred behaviour that's focused on winning and being dogmatic—towards player-centred behaviour, where everyone gets an opportunity, and feels valued.

So how do we help them think more broadly about player development and how do we also hold their sideline and changing-room behaviour to account?

Not just their immediate physical or verbal behaviour, but their overall approach to dealing with young people?

Participants in the report were asked what changes were most needed to keep young people involved longer. 

Participants in the report were asked what changes were most needed to keep young people involved longer. 

GAA.ie. What happens next now that this report has been published?

Peter Horgan: This report involved gathering evidence and engaging with members by speaking with clubs, volunteers, officials, players, coaches, parents and everyone involved in young people's sport. It builds a broad base of information that clubs, counties, provincial councils and national level committees can use when making decisions and policy changes so that those decisions can then be made on an informed basis. That's the process that is under way right now.

The report has been presented to the National Games Development Committee, for example, which leads policy on games development within the Association. The next stage is for those groups to review the evidence and existing practices in the counties and consider whether policy or practice changes are needed across the Association in this area.

It's important to distinguish between the research and the recommendations, which are put forward for consideration by the Association's decision-makers.

The field testing that we've done has provided us with a really nice insight into what happens when you modify playing numbers and modify pitch dimensions, but we're not saying it's the definitive piece of work that can happen in this space. There is more scope for better understanding, not alone the games program, but the games formats and competition formats that are provided for young players.

Paul Donnelly: I think the first thing to acknowledge is that this report isn't the finished article. It's a significant piece of research, but we recognise that there's further work to be done, particularly over the next year.

What the research does provide is a strong evidence base to inform discussion and future decision-making about how we organise juvenile Gaelic games.

And I think it's important to emphasise that we're not suggesting that recommendations should simply be introduced overnight. There needs to be further engagement and discussion with clubs, coaches, players and administrators. These are the people who are involved in delivering and experiencing our games every week, and their views have to be central to whatever happens next.

We also know that some counties are already experimenting with different playing formats and competition structures. I think there's a real opportunity to learn from that.

For example, with the agreement and cooperation of those counties, we could continue this research next year by monitoring how those approaches are working, understanding the experiences of players and coaches, and identifying what might be effective in different settings.

That would allow us to build on the evidence we already have, rather than simply introducing changes without understanding how they might work in practice.

And hopefully, towards the end of next year, that additional research and engagement could help inform the development of a more comprehensive and meaningful youth games framework.

I think we also need to recognise the scale of what we're talking about. Any consideration of changes to juvenile playing formats or competition structures is a significant undertaking. It needs to be carefully considered, informed by evidence and developed in partnership with the people who will ultimately be responsible for delivering it.

So, for me, this report is not the end of the process. It's an important step in a longer journey towards ensuring that our competition structures support player development, provide meaningful playing opportunities and encourage more young people to remain involved in Gaelic games.

And I think that's something everyone involved in Gaelic games should be able to support.

Michael McKay: This is a brilliant bit of work, I'm really proud of it, but you cannot read it and say that everything is grand.

I think this research presents a real challenge to policy makers and games managers in terms of how Gaelic games structurally can better provide for the development of all players rather than the development of the good player. The evidence we've gathered provides that challenge.

I think structurally within counties and across provinces there are conversations needed around how can we better support our players. So, the basic question to answer is how can the provision of Gaelic games make young people better players in terms of skill, and at the same time make them feel more welcome and involved?

‘Shaping the Future of Juvenile Gaelic Games: Evidence to Inform a Youth Games Framework’ can be viewed and downloaded below.